​1978 - Tom Callaghan (Windham)
1979 - Howard B. Dickenman (NFA)
1983 - George Butcher (East Lyme, Fitch, Glastonbury)
1985 - Morris Fabricant (Stonington)
1985 - Billy Gardner (Waterford, Minnesota Twins)
1987 - Ed Ferrigno (Windham)
1987 - Gerry Rousseau (Waterford)
1991 - Bill Mignault (Ledyard)
1994 - Bob Schaefer (Ledyard, MLB)

1995 - Judy Deeb (East Lyme)
​1996 - John D. “Jack” Long (Bacon Academy)
1998 - Rene Ledoux (NFA)​
1999 - Robert Haddad (Windham)
2000 - Douglas Sharples (St. Bernard)
2001 - Tim Ryan (NFA)
2003 - Jim Buonocore (Fitch, New London)
2004 - Dave Shea (Bacon Academy)
2008 - Gary Makowicki (NFA)
2009 - Ellen Mahoney (Ledyard)

2009 - Gilbert Varjas (New London)​
2010 - Jim Canty (Tourtellotte)
2014 - Brian T. Crudden (Windham)
2015 - Gerry Chester (Griswold, Ellis Tech, St. Bernard)
2017 - John Schiffner (Plainfield)
2018 - Gilbert LaPointe (NFA)
2018 - Marc Allard (Woodstock, Media)
2019 - Robin Deary Fillmore (Woodstock, Killingly)
2021 - Rich Bowen (Killingly)
2025 - Paul "Wally" Christensen (East Lyme)